How to set up an isotonicity problem
A solution going into the eye, the nose, or a vein should exert the same osmotic pressure as body fluids, which for pharmacy purposes means the same as 0.9% sodium chloride. A drug dissolved in water already contributes some osmotic pressure. The sodium chloride equivalent, or E-value, says how much: it is the grams of NaCl that have the same osmotic effect as 1 gram of the drug. From it you can work out how much NaCl the drug has already "used up" and how much you still need to add.
1. drug in the formula = % × volume → 2. NaCl equivalent = drug g × E → 3. NaCl to make the volume isotonic alone = 0.009 × volume → 4. NaCl to add = step 3 − step 2
The exam gives the E-value. The skill is the four-step setup, and the discipline is keeping every intermediate to full precision, because the final answer is a small number of grams and rounding at step 2 is enough to move its last digit.
Worked example 1
How many grams of sodium chloride are needed to make 30 mL of a 2% pilocarpine HCl solution isotonic? (E = 0.24)
drug = 2% × 30 = 0.6 g
NaCl equivalent of the drug = 0.6 × 0.24 = 0.144 g
NaCl for the volume alone = 0.009 × 30 = 0.27 g
NaCl to add = 0.27 − 0.144 = 0.126 g
Worked example 2
How many grams of sodium chloride are needed to make 15 mL of 2% lidocaine HCl isotonic? (E = 0.22)
drug = 2% × 15 = 0.3 g
NaCl equivalent of the drug = 0.3 × 0.22 = 0.066 g
NaCl for the volume alone = 0.009 × 15 = 0.135 g
NaCl to add = 0.135 − 0.066 = 0.069 g
When the answer comes out negative
If step 2 is bigger than step 3, the drug alone already makes the solution hypertonic, and no amount of NaCl fixes that. The E-value method only tells you how to raise tonicity. A 10% phenylephrine solution, for example, is hypertonic on its own. A question with that setup is testing whether you recognize it, and the answer is "none; the solution is already hypertonic," not a negative number of grams.
Using a different tonicity agent
Sometimes the agent to be added isn't sodium chloride, for example dextrose or boric acid, because NaCl is incompatible with the drug. Work steps 1 to 4 exactly as above to get the grams of NaCl that would be needed, then divide by the E-value of the substitute agent to convert. If the substitute's E-value is 0.18, then 0.126 g of NaCl is equivalent to 0.126 ÷ 0.18 = 0.7 g of the substitute. The question supplies that second E-value too.
Where students lose the points
- Steps 2 and 3 swapped in the subtraction. It's what the volume needs minus what the drug already provides. If your answer is negative and the drug is dilute, the subtraction is backwards.
- Percent applied as a whole number. 2% × 30 mL is 0.6 g, not 60.
- Rounding at step 2. 0.6 × 0.24 is exactly 0.144; keep it. If the product had been 0.1443, keep that too.
- Using 0.9 instead of 0.009. The isotonic reference is 0.9 g per 100 mL, which is 0.009 g per mL. Multiply by the volume in mL.
- Two drugs, one E-value. If the formula has two active ingredients, each has its own E-value and its own step 2. Add the two NaCl equivalents before subtracting from step 3.